Why don’t teachers teach something useful?

I rarely miss an opportunity to deride the American education system; one of my main complaints is that it often focuses on teaching obscure if not downright esoteric skill sets as opposed to the basic skills most people need to function in society. I, for instance, graduated from high school never having been taught to use a checkbook (I picked it up pretty quickly, but still.) There’s an article in the new New Yorker arguing that if the recent recession and housing market implosion has taught us anything, it’s that we need meaningful financial education.

We really need something more like a financial equivalent of drivers’ ed. There’s evidence that just improving basic calculation skills and inculcating a few key concepts could make a significant difference. One study of the few states that have mandated financial education in schools found that it had a surprisingly large impact on savings rates. And the Center for American Progress has found that, across the country, education and counselling by nonprofit organizations, like the Massachusetts Affordable Housing Alliance, have helped low-income families buy and hold onto homes, even during the housing bubble. The point isn’t to turn the average American into Warren Buffett but to help people avoid disasters and day-to-day choices that eat away at their bank accounts.

I couldn’t agree more. We teach algebra and calculus — which 90% of students won’t use — but we don’t teach them how to avoid getting screwed on a home loan or to recognize a credit card offer with insane terms. The reason of course is that the teachers unions are in bed with the American finance industry. And they all take their orders directly from the Mexican Elvis who lives in a UFO parked in the North Pole.

4 thoughts on “Why don’t teachers teach something useful?

  1. John Saleeby

    I think kids should be taught how to write sit com scripts, produce hip hop albums, and play drums for rock bands. Nobody seems to be doing any of these things very well and they’re all anybody seems to want to do. Oh, and late night talk show hosting – They ought to begin teaching that in First Grade.

  2. Angel

    I will agree. I never was taught anything like how to balance a checkbook or any basic common financial literacy. I did pick it up on my own over time, but there are things I wish I had known sooner. And yes, I had to take the whole bunch of math classes, including calc at one point, which I have never had to use since I left school. If we want to reform education, I think putting in some good financial literacy lessons (who knows, part of something like Home Ec., because yea, kids also could use some knowledge of how to care for their homes) would be a good start.

    P.S. Your blog was mentioned in a book I am reading (The Quotable Atheist), so made my way here.

    Best, and keep on blogging.

  3. Wil Post author

    Cool — thanks. Yeah, that atheist quote seems to keep traveling the Web.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *